Don’t get us wrong, we’re usually all about broccoli and kale—but come October, we love to indulge in our favorite Halloween candy (hey, it’s called balance!). Like us, you probably have a favorite treat you look forward to every Halloween, but why not switch it up this year by choosing a candy that’s perfect for your zodiac sign? We asked Kim Green, an astrologer from Valdosta, Georgia, to give us the scoop on which candy is best for your zodiac sign. Here’s what she had to say.

The Best Halloween Candy for Your Zodiac Sign

Aries: Red Hots

Taurus: Snickers

Gemini: Sour Patch Kids

Cancer: Milk Duds

Leo: Starburst

Virgo: Smarties

Libra: Kit Kat

Scorpio: Almond Joy

Sagittarius: Skittles

Capricorn: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Aquarius: Pop Rocks

Pisces: Swedish Fish